Once again Google is assisting the enemies of the Jewish People.
Dr. Andre Obler has written an enlightening summary of how Google is helping Israel's adversaries distort the historical narrative of the Jewish State.
The findings of Dr. Obler's paper for the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs follows:
Google Earth: A New Platform for Anti-Israel Propaganda
and Replacement Geography
Andre Oboler
Virtual Israel, as represented by Google Earth, is littered with orange dots, many of which claim to represent "Palestinian localities evacuated and destroyed after the 1948 Arab-Israeli war." Thus, Israel is depicted as a state born out of colonial conquest rather than the return of a people from exile. Each dot links to the "Palestine Remembered" site, where further information advancing this narrative can be obtained.
Many of the claims staked out in Google Earth present misinformation, and sites known to be ruins in 1946 are claimed to be villages destroyed in 1948. Arab villages which still exist today are listed as sites of destruction. The Google Earth initiative is not only creating a virtual Palestine, it is creating a falsification of history.
The concept of "replacement geography" replaces the historical connection of one people to the land with a connection between another people and the land. The inclusion of virtual Palestine, superimposed on Israel in the core layer of Google Earth is an example of replacement geography advanced by technology.
Those wishing to explore Israel in Google Earth are immediately taken to a politically motivated narrative unrelated to their quest. The promotion of a replacement narrative works against a compromise solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, inspiring absolutist positions rather than a negotiated settlement.
As a space engineer involved in development of among others earth observations satellites I was astonished to see that Google Earth is misused for politically motivated arguments.
I am sure that this is not the intention; moreover I know from my own visits that sites shown as destroyed by Israel have been ruins already in 1946.
The intention of space development is to bring people together and create an environment which allow all of us to live in respect with each other. False information is the basis for hate. I urge you to do something about it and remove the orange dots.
Thank you and all the best for now and the future
Peter Sachs
Amsterdam.
Posted by: Peter Sachs at June 29, 2008 8:23 AM
Also note that many of the kibbutzim are easily found on Google earth. Any body can use the information to Rocket Israeli targets.
Posted by: Joe Klien at June 28, 2008 1:20 PM
How can I email google, to let them know how displeased I am, with their attrocious behavior??
Posted by: Rev.D.L.LaBean at June 28, 2008 9:38 AM
I am surprised that google would isrepresent geography or history to such a degree, and would request they use their vast amount of information to research actual history .
Posted by: shirleyberent at June 28, 2008 7:29 AM
Goole please leave OUR little Israel alone.
We have enough ememys without you.
Posted by: sandra at June 28, 2008 1:31 AM
Thank you Abraham J. Rokach for your offer of help to Google..
Larry
Posted by: Larry Archer at June 27, 2008 5:41 PM
Thank you for the essay regarding Google Earth from Dr. Andre Oboler.
I respectfully suggest that a Google Earth overlay with an historically accurate depiction of Israel be made available to friends of the Jewish State.
As a structural engineer who has developed computer models of the Third Jerusalem Temple (the Temple of the Future) based on the Book of Ezekiel and traditional Commentaries -- including a model that can be inserted into Google Earth -- I will be pleased to contribute my work.
Viewing the Messianic-era Temple in Google Earth has been a morale-booster for me, and, I am sure, will be likewise for others, as well.
Posted by: Abraham J. Rokach at June 27, 2008 12:35 PM
I have written to Google with your complaint. Thank you for bringing it to my attention. It seemed odd that I was not quickly able to find a way to email them. :)
But, the mail system still works.
Thank you
Posted by: margi at June 27, 2008 9:55 AM
Post a Comment
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.onejerusalem.org/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1164
Listen now to the latest exclusive One Jerusalem Bloggers Conference Call with Caroline Glick, world journalist, policy-analyst and author of, Shackled Warrior: Israel and the Global Jihad.Caroline raises important points about the future of Israel, the centrality of Jerusalem, Barak Obama's anti-Israel advisers,...